Brands, you have a problem. Smarter and world-weary consumers are growing increasingly cynical of your efforts to win them over, especially if you don’t mean what you say — or help out when times are bad, as they have been for the last 15 months.
That’s the bottom-line finding of the 12th annual installment of Havas’ Meaningful Brands survey, which aimed to take the cultural and social temperature of consumers at the height of the pandemic. As might be expected, the findings represent a wake-up call of sorts for brands—and indirectly, for the agencies that help them reach consumers.
“Consumers truly are more informed, have new kinds of expectations about when and where and how a brand shows up, and some brands still aren’t getting it,” said Greg James, global chief strategy officer at Havas Media Group, the media arm of Havas. “I know it’s tricky right now, they fear a backlash, but especially the newer generation of consumers like Gen Z are informed and keen to hear brands show up in the right way.
“Agencies really do have to be strong partners for clients — when they ask us to challenge them, we have to,” he added. “Building strong, meaningful brands means making tough decisions you can stand by because they’re the right decisions for your particular category and your particular consumer.”
The Meaningful Brands survey found a deep skepticism across society: 71 percent of consumers said they have little faith that brands will deliver on their promises, saying they are tired of brands pretending they want to act for the good of society when they are mostly out to generate profits.
“We’ve been looking at this for 12 years now and ultimately, brands still aren’t doing enough in terms of really building loyalty and strong connection — particularly since in most categories in that time we’ve seen so much disruption,” said James.
Havas surveyed 395,000 consumers in 30 markets across the globe between July and September 2020 (at the height of the pandemic, not the happiest time in the world), about more than 2,000 brands across 21 industries.
Less than half the respondents (47 percent) say they trust brands when results from all the surveyed regions — which represented 30 countries — were averaged together. There remain some pockets of optimism, including China (where 74 percent expressed trust), India (69 percent) and Latin America, which includes Mexico, Brazil and Chile (67 percent). Interestingly, the lowest recorded trust level was found in East Asia (which includes Australia, Hong Kong and Korea), where only 24 percent trust brands.
And three out of four brands could disappear overnight and most people wouldn’t care, the survey found again. This has been one of the hallmarks of the Meaningful Brands survey in recent years; the number has hovered consistently in the low- to mid-70s range, but dropped from a high of 77 percent in 2019.
Notably, this year’s study highlighted that consumers have higher expectations for brands than ever. Nearly three out of four (73 percent) respondents think brands “must act now for the good of society and the planet.”
Further, they are willing to put their money where their mouths are: 64 percent of respondents said they prefer to buy from companies with a reputation for purpose as well as profit — a 10 point surge compared to the 2019 Meaningful Brands study.
Havas defines “meaningful” as a blend of:
- Functional (how a brand delivers on technology, price, support, ease of customer interactivity)
- Personal (how a brand fits into peoples’ lives)
- Collective (a brand’s role in society and culture).
Member ExclusiveDigiday+ Research: Agencies execs see more long-term value in the metaverse than blockchain
Marketing in the metaverse, although a long way off for most brands, has caught the attention of agency execs who see it's potential over other new technologies.
Why — and how — the IAB is developing new measurement standards for in-game ads
The task force was inspired by the MRC’s decision to release a September 2021 interim guidance memo discussing shortcomings in the IAB’s 2009 standards.
‘The absolute perfect person for it’: Naz Aletaha’s path to the top of League of Legends esports
Aletaha's success in growing Riot’s esports partnerships was integral in making League of Legends esports into a viable business, rather than a candy-colored marketing expense.
SponsoredWhat marketers need to know about the next frontier in consumer engagement￼
Talbott Roche, CEO and president, Blackhawk Network A marketer’s holy grail is deeply understanding the end-users of their company’s products and services. Marketers study demographics ad nauseam and create personas for customers to understand their needs and preferences better. And when the pandemic hit, everyone’s lives were fundamentally transformed. Customer playbooks changed instantly because, in […]
The 4A’s is telling its members how to crack down on unscrupulous ad tech players
The trade body representing media agencies urges 'simplicity' as advertisers demand transparency on things like dynamic take rates or the intricacies of content verification.
Black creators sign open letter to Twitch demanding improved safety and moderation tools
This isn’t the first time streamers have joined forces to protest Twitch’s safety and moderation practices; “hate raids,” targeted attacks against women and minority streamers by waves of aggressive bots, have been a consistent presence on the platform in recent years.